A recent BBC Watchdog investigation struck a chord with me. It highlighted something I have long felt is a real problem for independent traders selling quality goods: how do you compete fairly when the description on another product may not reflect what the customer is actually buying?
Watchdog bought 25 pieces of jewellery advertised as sterling silver or 925 silver from five online marketplaces. According to the BBC, laboratory testing found that only two could be classified as sterling silver. Eight contained cadmium above the legal limit.
Those findings relate to the items tested, not every seller on those platforms. But they raise an important question about how much confidence shoppers can place in a product description.
For me, this is about more than a disappointing purchase. It is about trust, the value of craftsmanship, and what happens when very different products are presented as though they are the same.
The price comparison that isn’t really a comparison
When you see two pieces of jewellery described as sterling silver, it is natural to compare their prices.
One may cost only a few pounds. Another, made by an independent jeweller, may cost considerably more. On a screen, both might look attractive. Both might use the same words in their descriptions.
What a photograph cannot show is whether those words are accurate.
If one piece is genuinely sterling silver and another is not, the customer is not comparing like with like. Yet the lower price can still become the benchmark against which the independent maker is judged.
That is the difficulty I have always seen. Honest pricing can look unreasonable when it is placed beside an inaccurate promise.
If the price looks too good to be true
My advice to shoppers is simple: if a piece advertised as sterling silver has an unbelievably low price, be wary. If it looks too good to be true, it may well be.
A remarkably cheap price is not proof that an item is falsely described, but it is a reason to pause rather than assume you have found a bargain. Ask what the piece is actually made from, whether it is solid sterling silver or merely silver-plated, and who is accountable for the description. If the answers are vague or unconvincing, I would walk away.
A bargain is only a bargain if you receive what you were promised. The words “sterling silver” in a listing should not be enough on their own to put those doubts to rest.
What goes into a handmade piece
At Ingot 47, I make sterling silver jewellery by hand here in the UK.
The price of a handmade piece reflects more than its appearance. There are materials, tools, design decisions and the time spent making and finishing it. There is also the experience behind the work: learning what works, refining techniques and paying attention to the small details that help a piece feel right.
Not all of that is immediately visible in a product photograph. But it is still part of what you are buying.
Independent makers should be able to explain the value of their work without sounding as though they are apologising for its price.
This isn’t about blaming shoppers
Everyone has a budget. Looking for an affordable gift or a small treat is entirely understandable.
And a lower price does not automatically mean a product is poor quality, just as a higher price does not automatically guarantee excellence.
The issue is honesty.
There is room for jewellery made from many different materials, at many different prices. What matters is that it is described accurately, so customers can make an informed choice.
If something is silver-coloured or silver-plated, that should be clear. A shopper choosing an inexpensive fashion accessory is making one decision. A shopper buying something described as sterling silver is making another.
They deserve to receive what they were promised.
The cost to independent businesses
Misleading descriptions do not just affect the person who buys the item. I believe they also make life harder for businesses trying to sell honestly.
They can distort expectations about what genuine materials and skilled work should cost. They can leave customers disappointed and more cautious about buying jewellery online. And they can mean that responsible makers spend more time explaining why their work costs what it does.
For an independent business, trust is personal. Our names and reputations sit behind the things we make.
That matters to me. I want customers to appreciate the design of a piece, but I also want them to understand what it is and why it has value.
Buying with confidence, not fear
My response to this investigation is not that everyone should stop shopping online, or that every marketplace seller should be viewed with suspicion. Many independent makers sell through marketplaces too.
Instead, I hope it encourages people to look beyond the photograph and the headline price.
Read the description. Look for clear information about materials, measurements and who is selling the piece. Ask questions if something is unclear. A useful answer tells you more than a string of impressive-sounding words.
You should not have to become a jewellery expert to buy a gift. But you should be able to expect an honest description.
A fair chance for quality
Supporting independent makers is not about paying more simply because a business is small. It is about recognising genuine materials, skilled work and the person accountable for what they sell.
I am not asking customers to ignore price. I am asking that we compare products on truthful terms.
Because when “sterling silver” means one thing in an independent maker’s workshop and something quite different in an online listing, the price tag is not telling the whole story.
And both shoppers and honest traders deserve better.
Source: BBC News: Jewellery sold as sterling silver on Amazon and Temu found to contain toxic chemicals.